Picking a mixed media sketchbook that takes wet and dry work
A few links on this page go to art supplies we describe. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
A sketchbook is the one art supply most people carry for years, and it is often chosen in about thirty seconds at a checkout counter. That is a pity, because the wrong book quietly shapes what you draw. Thin paper teaches you to avoid water. A book that will not lie flat teaches you to draw small and off to one side. A precious, expensive book teaches you to be careful, and careful is the enemy of a good sketchbook.
A mixed media sketchbook promises to solve most of that: paper heavy enough for ink and light washes, smooth enough for pencil, sturdy enough for a glue stick and a bit of collage. Some books keep that promise better than others. Here is how to tell them apart.
What "mixed media" really means
There is no standard for the label. On one cover it means a 90 lb sheet that tolerates a marker. On another it means a 140 lb paper close to watercolor stock. What the term usually describes is a paper that is:
- heavier than ordinary drawing paper, so it does not buckle at the first sign of water;
- sized well enough that ink lines stay sharp and washes do not soak straight through;
- smooth to medium in texture, so pencil, pen and brush all feel at home.
The test of a mixed media book is not how it handles any one medium perfectly, but how gracefully it handles all of them badly enough to be useful. It will never take a full wet-in-wet watercolor like a cotton block, and it will never be as silky for fine pencil as bristol. It sits in the middle on purpose.
Weight: the first number to check
Weight is printed on the cover in pounds (lb) and grams per square meter (gsm).
| Weight | What it tolerates | Typical use |
|---|---|---|
| 60 to 70 lb (about 100 to 120 gsm) | Pencil, dry media, light marker | General sketching; not really mixed media |
| 90 to 100 lb (about 150 to 165 gsm) | Ink, marker, a light wash with some cockling | Everyday mixed sketching |
| 120 to 140 lb (about 200 to 300 gsm) | Washes, gouache, glue, collage | Mixed media work you want to keep |
For a book that is genuinely useful with water, look for at least 90 lb, and ideally 120 lb or more if you plan to use watercolor or gouache regularly. Heavier paper means fewer pages for the same thickness, so a heavyweight book may have only 30 or 40 sheets. That is fine. A book you fill is worth more than a thick one you avoid.
If you mainly do watercolor, a dedicated watercolor sketchbook with 140 lb paper makes more sense than a mixed media one; the note on choosing watercolor paper covers the difference between cellulose and cotton sheets.
Surface and sizing
Mixed media papers are usually described as smooth, vellum or medium. A vellum surface has a slight tooth, which grips graphite and colored pencil better than a very smooth sheet and still lets a fineliner glide. Smooth surfaces favor pen and marker but can make pencil look pale and wash look streaky.
Sizing is the invisible coating that slows down how fast water and ink sink in. Good sizing keeps a drawn line crisp and lets you push a wash around for a moment before it settles. Weak sizing makes ink feather into fuzzy lines and washes dry with hard, blotchy edges. You cannot see sizing on the shelf, which is why the page test below matters.
Binding and how the book opens
How a sketchbook is bound decides whether you can draw across the spread, how it behaves on a lap and how long it survives a bag.
| Binding | Lies flat? | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Wire or spiral | Yes, and folds back on itself | Easy to work one page at a time; pages can tear out; spiral can catch in bags |
| Sewn (signatures) | Usually, if well made | Best for working across a two-page spread; durable |
| Glued (perfect bound) | Often not | Fine for small books; pages may pull out with heavy wet use |
| Pad with fold-over cover | Pages are meant to come out | More of a pad than a book; good for studies |
If you like drawing big landscapes across both pages, look for a sewn book that opens fully flat. If you want to work on one page at a time on a cramped train table, a spiral book that folds back on itself is more practical.
Size and shape
Small books (about 5 by 8 inches) travel everywhere and feel low-stakes, which makes them good for daily habits. Medium books (about 8 by 10 or 9 by 12 inches) give room for proper studies and color notes. Landscape-format books suit wide views and long still lifes; portrait-format books suit figures and single objects.
Many people end up with two: a small one that lives in a coat pocket and a larger one that stays on the table. A heavyweight mixed media pad is a good companion for the table. Loose sheets are easier to tape down for wetter work, and they let you try ideas before they go into a bound book.
The first-page test
When you open a new book, spend the first page on a test strip instead of a drawing. It takes ten minutes and tells you everything:
- Draw a short line with each pencil you use, from hard to soft. Note how dark the softest one gets and whether hard ones dent the page. The note on drawing pencil grades explains what to expect.
- Draw lines with a fineliner and a brush pen. Look for feathering under a magnifier.
- Lay a small patch of watercolor wash, then a darker second layer once dry. Watch for buckling, hard edges and show-through on the back.
- Paint a patch of gouache at creamy consistency.
- Glue a scrap of paper with a glue stick, then draw over the edge.
- Turn the page and look at the back. Ghosting is normal with heavy washes; ink bleeding through is not.
Write the date and what you learned next to each test. That page becomes a little manual for the book, and you will refer to it more than you expect.
Keeping the book used
The real challenge with sketchbooks is not paper but habit. A few tricks help:
- Break the first page on purpose. A test strip, a mess of swatches or a deliberately bad drawing removes the fear of spoiling a clean book.
- Date every page. Seeing progress over months is the best motivation there is.
- Leave the book open on the table, not shelved. Out of sight means out of use.
- Give yourself small, repeatable subjects: the same mug, the view from one window, your shoes. Repetition is where improvement happens.
When you finish a book, number its spine and start the next one straight away. For more on routines, see the other notes on studio habits.
Matching the book to the way you work
Before buying, think about where most of your sketching happens. If it is mostly at a table with time to spare, a larger sewn book with heavy paper lets you work slowly and wet. If it is on trains, in cafés and on walks, size and binding matter more than paper weight: a small spiral book that folds back on itself, with paper just heavy enough for a quick wash, gets used far more often than a beautiful book left at home.
Think too about the media you actually use, not the ones you hope to use. Someone who sketches in fineliner and adds a little watercolor needs a smooth, well-sized surface and a modest weight. Someone who works in charcoal and pastel needs some tooth and does not care much about wet strength. A person who glues in tickets and labels needs sturdy pages and a binding that can cope with the extra bulk.
Buying one book at a time and noting what you liked and disliked about it, inside the back cover, is the surest way to find your favorite.
Questions people ask
Can I use acrylic paint in a mixed media sketchbook?
Thin acrylic, yes, on heavier papers. Acrylic dries into a plastic film, so pages painted heavily may stick together if closed before they are fully dry. Slip a sheet of wax paper between them for the first day.
Why does my watercolor look dull in a sketchbook?
Many mixed media papers absorb pigment faster than watercolor paper, so washes dry lighter and flatter. Use a little more pigment, work in fewer, bolder layers and accept that the book is for notes, not exhibition pieces.
Are toned sketchbooks worth trying?
Yes. Gray or tan paper lets you draw darks in pencil or ink and add highlights in white gouache or white pencil, which is a fast way to learn about light. Test the paper weight just as you would with white books.
